12 Broadway and Off-Broadway Shows Perfect for Date Night

Lists   12 Broadway and Off-Broadway Shows Perfect for Date Night
 
From brash comedies with a big heart to sweeping romances, these musicals are the ticket for a night out with your special someone.
Date Night graphic

Whether it’s Valentine’s Day, an anniversary, or just a night out together, the theatre is the perfect place for an intimate moment. Find inspiration in the love stories at the center of each of these Broadway and Off-Broadway musicals.

See the full listing of currently running Broadway shows here.

See the full listing of currently running Off-Broadway shows here.

See if any of these shows are coming to a city near you!

BROADWAY

Aladdin
New Amsterdam Theatre
Open-ended run

Courtney Reed and Adam Jacobs
Courtney Reed and Adam Jacobs Deen Van Meer

The Broadway musical based on the Disney-animated classic invites you to a whole new world of showstopping surprises. With all of your favorite songs from the original film (from “One Jump” to “Friend Like Me” to, yes, “A Whole New World”) and new tunes written by original composer Alan Menken, the show is the perfect blend of nostalgia and the unexpected. Let the love story of Princess Jasmine and Aladdin—and the showstopping glitz and magic of the Genie and Araba—sweep you off your feet.

Watch: ALAN MENKEN REVEALS THE ORIGINS OF HIS FAMOUS SONG ‘A WHOLE NEW WORLD’

Anastasia
Broadhurst Theatre
Closing March 31, 2019

Anastasia_Broadway_Cody_Simpson_Production_Photos_2018_HR
Christy Altomare and Cody Simpson Evan Zimmerman/MurphyMade

The story of Russian’s lost Romanov princess, first musicalized on the screen by the Tony-winning team Lynn Ahrens and Stephen Flaherty (Ragtime), opened on Broadway in 2017. As Anya searches for home, love, and family she meets Dmitry and Vlad, who are searching for a woman to play the lost Princess Anastasia in order to con the Grand Duchess into believing they’ve found her granddaughter—and take home a hefty reward. But unexpected sparks fly between Anya and Dmitry (and chemistry bubbles between Vlad and Countess Lily) leading to complications. Will love conquer all when Anya finds out the truth? Traveling from St. Petersburg to Paris, the City of Love, the stunning costumes and soaring score set the perfect mood.

The Band’s Visit
Ethel Barrymore Theatre
Closing April 7, 2019

The_Band's_Visit_Broadway_Production_Photo_2017_0251_Tony Shalhoub, Katrina Lenk in THE BAND'S VISIT, Photo by Matthew Murphy, 2017_HR.jpg
Tony Shalhoub and Katrina Lenk Matthew Murphy

The 2018 Tony-winning Best Musical isn’t a boy-meets-girl type of love story, but love percolates throughout. The mysticism in the air of the piece will captivate you and your date. The story follows an Egyptian Police Orchestra that winds up in the Israeli desert town Bet Hatikva rather than the cultural epicenter Petah Tikva; when they’re stranded for the night, the locals take them in. Sparks fly between leading lady Dina and leading man Tewfiq, but in an unconventional way. And a buddy romance between Papi and Haled emerges when the latter teaches Papi how to woo the ladies in the jazz ballad “Haled’s Song of Love.” If you’re looking for intimate theatre, this is it.

Watch: COMPOSER-LYRICIST DAVID YAZBEK DESCRBIES ‘HALED’S SONG ABOUT LOVE’

Find discount tickets toThe Band’s Visit here.

Kiss Me, Kate
Studio 54
Open-ended run (Begins previews February 14)

Kiss_Me_Kate_Broadway_Rehearsal_Photos_2019_HR
Kelli O'Hara and Will Chase Jenny Anderson

Based on Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew, this revival of the Cole Porter meta-musical stars Tony winner Kelli O’Hara and Tony nominee Will Chase as actors Lilli Vanessi and Fred Graham putting on a musical version of The Taming of the Shrew. The two also happen to be exes and Lilli is set to be remarried. Meanwhile Fred fancies young star Lois, who is actually seeing her co-star Bill. With jealous lovers, old flames, budding romances, a hot jazz score, and a pair of hilarious old-school gangsters, the new production from Roundabout Theatre Company (which features skillful revisions to better reflect 2019) makes for an ideal evening of musical comedy.

Find discount tickets to Kiss Me, Kate here.

The Lion King
Minskoff Theatre
Open-ended run

The_Lion_King_Broadway_Production_Photo_Christopher_Jackson_as_Simba_Photo_by_Ken_Van_Sickle_HR.jpg
Christopher Jackson Ken Van Sickle

Can you feel the love tonight? Julie Taymor’s incomparable mounting of the beloved Disney-animated film has been running on Broadway for over two decades. As with Aladdin, there is a nostalgia factor filling the air, but the love story between Simba and Nala (and the chorus cooing “Can You Feel the Love Tonight?”) makes this a fitting choice for date night. Though the tragedy of Mufasa will surely make you weep, the comedy of Timon and Pumbaa will make you laugh, and the Disney magic of it all will make your remember the night forever.

Read: WHAT KEEPS THE LION KING GOING 21 YEARS AND COUNTING

The Phantom of the Opera
Majestic Theatre
Open-ended run

The_Phantom_of_the_Opera_Broadway_Ben_Crawford_Kaley_Ann_Voorhees_2019_HR.jpg
Ben Crawford and Kaley Ann Voorhees Matthew Murphy

One of the most romantic shows to ever hit the Broadway stage, The Phantom of the Opera is the longest-running Broadway show in history. Young ballerina Christine Daaé ascends to opera star when the Phantom of the Paris Opera House begins to tutor her. But her talent and beauty also capture the attention of her childhood companion Raoul, the Vicomte de Chagny and patron of the opera. With a stunning score by Andrew Lloyd Webber, including songs like “Think Of Me,” “Music of the Night,” and “All I Ask Of You,” the production from director Harold Prince still simmers with passion, desire, sensuality, and majesty.

Read: 30 LITTLE KNOWN PHANTOM FACTS AND BACKSTAGE STORIES

Find discount tickets to The Phantom of the Opera here.

Pretty Woman The Musical
Nederlander Theatre
Open-ended run

Pretty_Woman_Broadway_Production_Photo_2018_Samantha Barks and Andy Karl in PRETTY WOMAN THE MUSICAL, Photo by Matthew Murphy, 2018_HR.jpg
Samantha Barks and Andy Karl Matthew Murphy

If you love the Garry Marshall film starring Julia Roberts and Richard Gere, you’ll fall head over heels for the Broadway musical. Samantha Barks (the Les Misérables film) and Tony nominee Andy Karl (Groundhog Day, Rocky) play the charming Vivian and the guarded businessman Edward in a faithful adaptation of the 1990 movie. Add in music from “Run To You” composer Bryan Adam and Jim Vallance, sexy costumes by Gregg Barnes, and strong choreography from director-choreographer Jerry Mitchell, and you’ve got a recipe for a fabulous date night out on the town.

LISTEN TO ‘YOU AND I’ FROM PRETTY WOMAN THE MUSICAL

The Prom
Longacre Theatre
Open-ended run

The_Prom_Broadway_Production_Photo_2018_4_758.6672_Isabelle McCalla and Caitlin Kinnunen in THE PROM, Photo by Deen van Meer, 2018_HR.jpg
Isabelle McCalla and Caitlin Kinnunen Deen van Meer

This original laugh-out-loud musical comedy from director-choreographer Casey Nicholaw (The Book of Mormon) truly has it all—including the only same-sex love story on Broadway. Emma just wants to take her girlfriend Alyssa to their high school prom, but the PTA proves close-minded. When four Broadway stars, who deeply need to rehab their narcissistic public image, and their publicist learn about the story, they hitch a ride from NYC to Indiana to take up Emma’s cause. Written with hilarity and heart by Bob Martin (The Drowsy Chaperone), the romp zings with the bonus of inside-theatre humor. Plus, you’ll walk out of the house humming songs like “Dance With You” and “Tonight Belongs to You” by Matt Sklar and Chad Beguelin (The Wedding Singer). What’s better than a date to The Prom?

Watch: HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PROM

Find discount tickets to The Prom here.

Waitress
Brooks Atkinson Theatre
Open-ended run

Drew Gehling and Jessie Mueller in <i>Waitress</i>
Drew Gehling and Jessie Mueller in Waitress Jeremy Daniel

Leave it to Sara Bareilles to write a sensitive yet powerful score for the musical with a fiercely loving woman at its center. Written by Jessie Nelson and directed by Diane Paulus, Waitress is the adaptation of the 2007 Adrienne Shelley film about Jenna, a server at Joe’s Pie Diner with an extraordinary taste for baking that helps her escape her unhappy marriage—at least in her mind. When Jenna finds herself “betrayed by my eggs” and pregnant, an unexpected but steamy affair blossoms between her and her gynecologist. Meanwhile, the charming love story between her friend Dawn and Ogie and the surprising relationship in which her friend Becky finds herself prove that love can always surprise us. You’ll melt from songs like “You Matter To Me” and “Bad Idea,” and crack up from “You’re Never Gettin’ Rid of Me.” Plus, you and your date can share a bite of fresh-baked pie. One slice, two spoons.

Read: WAITRESS CHURNS OUT FRESHLY BAKED PIES EVERY SINGLE PERFORMANCE

Find discount tickets to Waitress here.

OFF-BROADWAY

Avenue Q
New World Stages
Closing April 28, 2019

Stephanie D&#39;Abruzzo and John Tartaglia
Stephanie D'Abruzzo and John Tartaglia Carol Rosegg

If you’re looking for a night out where you and your date can just laugh really hard, then look no further than the raunchy Avenue Q. Time is running short to catch the 2004 Tony-winning Best Musical before it leaves NYC for good. Modeled as a kind of adult Sesame Street, with puppets and humans cohabitating at the titular address, the story begins as Princeton graduates from college and finds solace in his neighbors: washed up star and building super Gary Coleman, kindergarten teacher Kate Monster, roommates Rod and Nicky, husband-and-wife duo Brian and Christmas Eve, and…Trekkie Monster. The love story comes with the endearing Princeton and Kate, with some will-they, won’t-they charm. You’ll roar from songs by EGOT winner Robert Lopez and Jeff Marx like “Everyone’s a Little Bit Racist,” “Schadenfreude,” and “For Now.”

Find discount tickets to Avenue Q here.

Chick Flick The Musical
Westside Theatre

Chick_Flick_Westside_Theatre_Cast_Promo_Shoot_2019_HR
Megan Sikora, Carla Duren, Lindsay Nicole Chambers, and Sharon Catherine Brown Evan Zimmerman/MurphyMade

On sale through June 29 (Begins performances February 21)
Instead of watching When Harry Met Sally for the hundredth time, take in this ode to romantic comedies. Weaving in the life lessons from beloved chick flicks, the musical from Suzy Conn centers on Karen, Dawn, Sheila, and Meg as they tuck in for a night of drinking, relaxing, and watching a rom-com. As the booze flows, relationship drama and career catastrophes ensue—but perhaps chick flicks can save the day? Cozy up with your significant other and feel the love bloom.


The Other Josh Cohen
Westside Theatre
Closing April 28, 2019

The_Other_Josh_Cohen_Westside Theatre_Production_Photo_2018_3_575_The Company of THE OTHER JOSH COHEN (c) Cailtin McNaney_HR.jpg
Company Caitlin McNaney

Longtime friends and musical theatre talents Steve Rosen and David Rossmer first premiered The Other Josh Cohen—then known as V-Day—as part of NYMF. After decades of dating in New York, the aired their frustrations by putting their struggle—and all its absurdities—onstage. Josh Cohen is single and broke. When his apartment is robbed just days before Valentine’s Day, he discovers the one thing left behind was a Neil Diamond CD. With the arrival of a strange letter, everything begins to change. Maybe The Other Josh Cohen is the good luck charm you need.

Read: HOW A GAME OF MARIO KART, A NEIL DIAMOND CD, AND A GUITAR LED TO OFF-BROADWAY’S HIT THE OTHER JOSH COHEN

Find discount tickets to The Other Josh Cohen here.

Shop the Playbill Store for all
Aladdin souvenirs and merchandise
 
Recommended Reading:
 X

Blocking belongs
on the stage,
not on websites.

Our website is made possible by
displaying online advertisements to our visitors.

Please consider supporting us by
whitelisting playbill.com with your ad blocker.
Thank you!