• 
• Harry Belafonte
• Singer of "Acorn in the Meadow"
  Singer of "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Singer of "Mark Twain"
  

• 
• Polly Bergen
• Meg
  Singer of "Fini"
  Singer of "I Dare to Dream"
  Singer of "The Earth and the Sky"
  

Replacement

• 
• Billy DeWolfe
• David
  Laurie
  Mrs. B
  The Butler
  The Butler
  

• 
• Hermione Gingold
• Amy
  Bobo
  Miss Reingold
  Mrs. A
  Singer of "Which Witch?"
  The Cellist
  The Lady
  Amy
  

• 
• Orson Bean
• Chinese Monologue performer
  Mike Hammer
  Singer of "Merry Little Minuet"
  The New Manager
  

• 
• Jimmy Albright
• Butler
  Guest at the Ball
  Pierrot Ensemble
  

• 
• Lee Theodore
• Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  Train Bearer
  

• 
• Hank Brunjes
• Bridegroom
  Guest at the Ball
  Pierrot Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Carleton Carpenter
• Harlequin
  Man
  Singer & Dancer, "When Am I Going to Meet Your Mother?"
  The Pierrot of 1953
  The Song Plugger
  

• 
• Ronald Cecill
• Bridegroom
  Butler
  Guest at the Ball
  Pierrot Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Dean Crane
• Pierrot Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  The Student
  Witch Doctor
  

Replacement

• 
• Nanci Crompton
• Beth
  Columbine
  The Bouquet
  The Nightingale
  

• 
• Imelda De Martin
• Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  Train Bearer
  

• 
• Elaine Dunn
• Jo
  Singer & Dancer, "When Am I Going to Meet Your Mother?"
  The Pierrette of 1953
  

• 
• Dorothy Dushock
• Guest at the Ball
  Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  Train Bearer
  

• 
• Jay Harnick
• Bridegroom
  Chorus
  Sedan Chair Bearer
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  The Man in the Box
  

• 
• Colleen Hutchins
• Chorus
  Dancer in "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Guest at the Ball
  Queen
  Second Secretary
  The Spring Bride
  

• 
• James Jewell
• Pierrot
  Singer of "Nightingale, Bring Me a Rose"
  

Replacement

• 
• Larry Kert
• Bridegroom
  Chorus
  Sedan Chair Bearer
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Robert Kole
• Bridegroom
  Chorus
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Gerard Leavitt
• Bridegroom
  Pierrot Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  The Prince
  

• 
• Celia Lipton
• Pierrette
  Rebecca
  Singer of "If Every Month Were June"
  The Story Teller
  

• 
• Greb Lober
• Guest at the Ball
  Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Tina Louise
• Chorus
  Guest at the Ball
  Lady
  Queen
  

• 
• Ralph McWilliams
• Bridegroom
  Butler
  Guest at the Ball
  Pierrot Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Kay Medford
• Fifi
  First Secretary
  Marmee
  Sally Duprey
  

• 
• Jacqueline Mickles
• Chorus
  Lady
  Queen
  The Autumn Bride
  

• 
• Harry Mimmo
• Puncinello
  

• 
• Ilona Murai
• Dancer in "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Louise
  Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Margot Myers
• Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  The Coquette
  

• 
• Gwen Neilson
• Guest at the Ball
  Maid
  Pierrette Ensemble
  Train Bearer
  

• 
• George Reeder
• Bridegroom
  Chorus
  Dancer in "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Guest at the Ball
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Siri
• Chorus
  Guest at the Ball
  The Summer Bride
  

• 
• Gloria Smith
• Dancer in "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Pierrette Ensemble
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Millard Thomas
• Guitarist for "Mark Twain"
  

• 
• Kenneth Urmston
• Butler
  Singer in "Tin Pan Alley"
  

• 
• Monique Van Vooren
• Chorus
  Dancer in "Hold 'Em Joe"
  Guest at the Ball
  Lady
  Queen
  The Winter Bride
  

• 
• Toni Wheelis
• Maid
  

• 
• Imelda De Martin
• Beth
  Columbine
  The Bouquet
  The Nightingale
  

• 
• Kenneth Harvey
• Cornelius
  David
  Laurie
  Mrs. B
  The Butler
  

Replacement

• 
• Larry Kert
• Dancer
  Harlequin
  Man
  Singer
  The Pierrot of 1953
  The Song Plugger
  

Replacement

• 
• Gwen Neilson
• Dancer
  Jo
  Singer
  The Pierrette of 1953
  

Replacement

• 
• Alice Pearce
• Amy
  Bobo
  Miss Reingold
  Mrs. A
  Singer
  The Cellist
  The Lady
  

Replacement

• 
• Toni Wheelis
• Dancer
  Jo
  Singer
  The Pierrette of 1953
  

Replacement

• 
• Buster Davis
• Musical Director
  

• 
• Jean Kerr
• Sketches
  

• 
• Sumner Lock-Elliot
• Writer
  

• 
• Arthur Macrae
• Sketches
  

• 
• Herbert Farjeon
• Sketches
  

• 
• Lauri Wylie
• Sketches
  

• 
• William K. Wells
• Sketches by
  

• 
• Richard Adler
• Music
  Lyrics
  

• 
• Jerry Ross
• Music
  Lyrics
  

• 
• Cy Coleman
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• Michael Grace
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  Producer
  

• 
• Joseph McCarthy
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• Henry Sullivan
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• John Rox
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• Bart Howard
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• Harry Belafonte
• Additional music
  Additional lyrics
  

• 
• John Murray Anderson
• Conception
  Staging
  

• 
• Donald Saddler
• Dances and Musical Numbers Staged
  

• 
• Cyril Ritchard
• Sketches Directed
  

• 
• Raoul Pène Du Bois
• Scenic Design
  

• 
• Thomas Becher
• Costume Design
  

• 
• Ted Royal
• Music Orchestrations
  

• 
• Gerald Alters
• Dance Arrangements
  

• 
• Buster Davis
• Vocal Arrangements
  

• 
• Arthur Barkow
• Production Stage Manager
  

• 
• Perry Bruskin
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Dennis Murray
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Manning Gurian
• Company Manager
  

• 
• Sol Jacobson
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Lewis Harmon
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Stanley Gilkey
• Producer
  

• 
• Harry Rigby
• Producer