(Christine Daaé) and Norm Lewis
(The Phantom), the newest stars of Andrew Lloyd Webber
's The Phantom of the Opera
, took the stage for a curtain call after their first performance on May 12. Fans and castmates alike celebrated the pair, while Boggess (who had a previous run as Christine Daaé on Broadway from Jan. 21, 2013 - Mar. 2, 2013) made it clear who she was cheering for. See the Photo Call
as Lewis donned the Phantom mask for the first time.